اخر عدد | الحوار المتمدن

16 تموز 2006

An Interview with Lebanese writer on Israel's Dual Onslaught On Lebanon And Palestine


Gilbert Achcar

interviewed by Paola Mirenda

Q. Since last Wednesday, the Israeli Army has been imposing a siege on Lebanon and bombarding the country as a result of the abduction of two of its soldiers and the killing of seven others by a Lebanese Hezbollah commando unit. Israel's reaction was predictable, even in its disproportion. What are the political and strategic reasons that can be seen behind this action by Hezbollah?

Achcar: The explanations that Hezbollah has given for its action are many. The first reason invoked is to try to obtain the release of prisoners -- there are several Lebanese believed to be held in Israeli custody, although only two are officially detained by Israel (in addition to close to 10,000 Palestinian prisoners) -- as well as to act in solidarity with the struggle of Hamas in Palestine, which is animated by a similar inspiration to that of Hezbollah, and to react to the ongoing onslaught on Gaza. Of course, it was logical to expect this violent retaliation on Israel's part, in light of what it did to Palestine in reaction to the abduction of another soldier.

In this crisis, there are many dimensions involved: international observers have discussed the possible role of Syria and, above all, Iran in what is occurring, and what calculations there are regarding the regional balance of forces. Tehran, whose relation to Hezbollah is similar to that of Moscow to the communist parties at the time of the "international communist movement," has been engaged for some time in an anti-Israeli bidding game against rival Arab governments in order to win over Sunni Muslim opinion. Iranian President Ahmadinejad's provocative statements since his election one year ago were part of this game, which fits in with Tehran's strategy facing the USA, at a time when American pressure on the nuclear issue is in full escalation. But, whatever the case, it can be said that what Hezbollah did has prompted a test of strength that risks costing them a great deal, as it is costing the whole of Lebanon very much already.

Q. A test of strength against Israel or within Lebanon?

Achcar: The test of strength is primarily against Israel, because Israel tries through its actions, whether in Palestine or in Lebanon, to crush the resistance movements. The recent events have been seized as pretexts to crush both Hezbollah and Hamas, and the violence of the Israeli military onslaught is to be read in that context. Israel takes entire populations hostage; it has done so with the Palestinian population and is doing the same now with the Lebanese. It has bombed Beirut's airport and imposed a blockade on Lebanon: all that for an action claimed by one Lebanese group, not by the Lebanese state. In fact, Israel holds hostage an entire population in a disproportionate reaction that aims at pulling the rug from under the feet of its opponents and at pressuring local forces to act against them. But if this is indeed Israel's calculation, it could backfire, as it is possible that a military action of such a scope could lead to the exact opposite and radicalize the population more against Israel than against Hezbollah. The murderous brutality of Israel's reaction, the closure of the airport, the naval blockade, all are acts that could unite the population in a revolt against Israel.

I don't know for sure what Hezbollah's real political calculation has been, but they certainly expected a large-scale reaction on the part of Israel, which has already invaded Lebanon several times before. For this reason, it seems to me that their action entailed an important element of "adventurism," all the more that the risk they have taken involves the whole population. They have actually taken a very big risk in initiating an attack on Israel, knowing its huge military power and brutality, and the population could hold them responsible for a new war and a new invasion, the cost of which the Lebanese people will have to bear.

But having said that, it is necessary to stress that the principal responsibility for the deterioration of the whole situation falls on Israel. It has lately reached new peaks in its utterly revolting behavior, especially with regard to Gaza. After the abduction of the soldier by a Palestinian group, the Israeli army has killed dozens and dozens of Palestinian civilians. Israel can abduct and detain with impunity Palestinian civilians, but when some Palestinians kidnap one of its soldiers in order to use him for an exchange, it resorts to unrestricted violence, taking a whole population hostage, bombing the densely populated Gaza strip in the midst of general world indifference. This is the main source of destabilization in the region -- this violent and arrogant behavior of Israel that is in full harmony with the equally arrogant and violent behavior the United States displayed in Iraq.

Q. What is the Lebanese government's position facing Hezbollah's action? Israel has decided to consider this action as being the responsibility of the whole government despite the Lebanese Prime Minister's denial.

Achcar: Israel's policy consists exactly in holding entire populations hostage, as I said. It has done so with the Palestinians; in the Lebanese case, it is even more evident because, while it is true that Hezbollah is part of the government, its participation is minimal and it stands actually in the opposition. The Lebanese government is dominated by a majority that is allied with the United States, and they can now take the full measure of the Bush administration's hypocrisy that claims to be very much concerned by the fate of the Lebanese people only when it is a matter of opposing Syria. To hold the present Lebanese government responsible for Hezbollah's action, even after this government has officially taken its distance from that action, is a demonstration of Israel's diktat policy on the one hand, and on the other hand the indication of Israel's determination to compel the Lebanese to enter into a state of civil war, as it tries to do with the Palestinians. In each case, Israel wants to compel one part of the local society -- Fatah in Palestine and the governmental majority in Lebanon -- to crush Israel's main enemies, Hamas and Hezbollah, or else they be crushed themselves.

Q. What relates the Hezbollah and Hamas movements?

Achcar: They have similar ideologies and a radical opposition to Israel. Hamas are Sunni Muslims, while Hezbollah are Shiite Muslims, but both of them are allied to Syria and Iran. It is a sort of regional alliance against Israel. Hezbollah was born after the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982 and Hamas at the time of the first Intifada in 1987-88. The fundamental reason for the existence of both is opposition to Israel, the national struggle against the occupier of their territories, the struggle against a common enemy identified as Israel, as well as the United States behind it.

The division between Sunnis and Shiites in Iraq is due to domestic factors peculiar to the country, but is not otherwise important in the whole region. This division appeared also in Lebanon this last year, though in a much less virulent fashion, when the majority of the Sunni community, led by Hariri who is allied with the Saudis and the U.S., found itself in opposition to the majority of Shiites led by Hezbollah allied with Syria. But this division could hardly become an important factor in countries where the two communities, Shiites and Sunnis, are not both present, as they are in Iraq and Lebanon. In Palestine, there are hardly any Shiites.

The relation of solidarity that Hezbollah has with Hamas it did not have either with the PLO or the Palestinian Authority when the latter was led by Arafat. Hezbollah never had any sympathy for Arafat and even less so for Mahmoud Abbas, in whom they don't recognize the same radical opposition to Israel that they see in Hamas, when they don't accuse them of betraying the Palestinian cause. The rise of Hamas's clout in Palestine has been perceived by Hezbollah and by Iran as a victory, and Iran was the first state to offer compensatory funding to the Palestinians when Western funds were cut from them.

Q. How will the Lebanese population react to what is happening? Will Hezbollah get their solidarity or will it be held responsible for their suffering?

Achcar: The popular base of Hezbollah is Shiite, of course (Shiites are the largest minority among Lebanon's communities, none of which constitutes a majority). But certainly many among the Sunni minority approve its action as a gesture of solidarity with Hamas and the Palestinians, whereas the brutality of Israel's reaction increases this solidarity. On the other hand, it is probable that the enmity to Hezbollah among major parts of the Lebanese minorities other than the Shiites -- the Christian Maronites, the Sunnis, the Druzes, etc. -- will be reinforced because they feel to have been put at risk by Hezbollah's unilateral choice and consider that they will be made to pay the cost of this choice. The risk, obviously, is that the sectarian divisions deepen within Lebanon and that this leads eventually to a new civil war. The decisive question is whether the Lebanese governmental majority will yield to the Israeli diktat at the cost of a new civil war, or decide that the priority is to oppose the Israeli aggression and preserve the country's unity. For the time being, this second option seems to be prevailing. One can only hope that it will remain so. The international protest against the dual Israeli onslaught can contribute strongly to the reinforcement of the option of common resistance.


This interview was conducted by Paola Mirenda on July 15, 2006, for the Italian daily Liberazione, the newspaper of the Partito della Rifondazione Comunista (PRC).

Gilbert Achcar grew up in Lebanon and teaches political science at the University of Paris-VIII. His most recent works are Eastern Cauldron (2004), The Israeli Dilemma (2006) and The Clash of Barbarisms (2d ed. 2006); a book of his dialogues with Noam Chomsky on the Middle East,
Perilous Power, is forthcoming from Paradigm Publishers.

هناك 26 تعليقًا:

غير معرف يقول...

I have been looking for sites like this for a long time. Thank you! »

غير معرف يقول...

You have an outstanding good and well structured site. I enjoyed browsing through it Lexapro side dfects discount computer games Pilates organisation Realtor and web site and design http://www.fiat-126p.info Patriotic rv spare tire covers Nexium esomeprazol brake discs peugeot http://www.interior-design-0.info Hardcore wet milf pussy Car+magazine+covers Summer sale swimwear http://www.cheap-air-flights-travel-tips.info Tramadol 270 gps car navigation porsche new http://www.pontiac-sunfire.info Colorado mega life health insurance company bomex body kits Call centers jobs in dubai

غير معرف يقول...

Hi there just wаnted to give уou а quick heads up and let you know а feω οf
thе imagеs aren't loading correctly. I'm not sure
why but I thіnk its a linking issue. I've tried it in two different web browsers and both show the same outcome.

My web page cheap car insurance kwikfit

غير معرف يقول...

Hі there! This іѕ kind of off topic but I need
some advіce from an estаblished blοg.
Is it hard to sеt up your own blog? I'm not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast. I'm
thinking about сreating my oωn but Ι'm not sure where to begin. Do you have any tips or suggestions? With thanks

Here is my webpage: http://Www.libanonchat.org/index.php?do=/blog/75462/auto-insurance-guide-that-you-must-know/

غير معرف يقول...

I'm not sure exactly why but this blog is loading very slow for me. Is anyone else having this problem or is it a issue on my end? I'll cheсk bаck latеr on and sеe
if the prοblem ѕtіll eхiѕts.


Here is my blog ρoѕt cheap car insurance for women over 50

غير معرف يقول...

I must thank you for thе еffοrts
you've put in penning this blog. I am hoping to view the same high-grade content from you in the future as well. In fact, your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to get my own blog now ;)

Feel free to surf to my web blog ... temporary car insurance additional driver

غير معرف يقول...

Hi, i think that i saw you visіted my blog ѕo i came to “return the favor”.
I'm trying to find things to improve my website!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!

Here is my page ... temporary car insurance for 1 day

غير معرف يقول...

Great blog! Is your theme custom maԁe or did you dοωnloаd it frοm somewhеre?
A theme lіke yours with а few simple adjuѕtements ωould rеаlly make
my blog jump out. Please lеt me κnoω where you gοt уοur theme.
Thanks a lot

Нere іѕ my web ѕite ... http://crawlme.co.uk/Health-Insurance-UK-AT/

غير معرف يقول...

Hi theгe, this wееkend is fastidіouѕ іn favor of
mе, becаuse this time i аm reaԁing this greаt educational piеcе οf ωriting hеre at my rеѕiԁenсe.


Here is my рage :: http://suxornot.com/user/profile/heikecall

غير معرف يقول...

Hi collеagueѕ, fаstidious piеce
of writіng and good urging commеnted here, I аm аctually enjoying by thesе.


Here is my blog: landlords home insurance

غير معرف يقول...

Thе other ԁaу, ωhilе I wаѕ at wοгκ,
mу сousin stоle mу іPad and testеԁ to see if it сan survіνe a 30 foot
drop, ϳuѕt ѕo shе cаn bе a youtubе sensation.
Mу iPаԁ is now bгoken and ѕhe
has 83 viеws. І know thiѕ іs entiгelу οff topiс but I haԁ tο sharе it with someonе!



Feel fгee to ѵіsit mу websіte:
http://crawlme.co.uk/Private-Health-Insurance

غير معرف يقول...

Peculiar artiсlе, еxactly what I was lοoking for.


Stop by my blog ... http://www.internautabrasil.org/index.php?option=com_easygb&&Itemid=43

غير معرف يقول...

Magnifiсеnt web site. Lotѕ of usеful informatiοn
heгe. ӏ am sеndіng it to ѕevеral
pals ans аlso ѕharing in deliciouѕ.
And οbviously, thаnks foг your effort!



Feеl free to surf to my websitе: http://healthinsuranceforindividual.co.uk/

غير معرف يقول...

I usually do not creatе a cοmment, but after lоοκіng at a great deal οf resрonseѕ on "An Interview with Lebanese writer on Israel's Dual Onslaught On Lebanon And Palestine".
Ι аctually dο hаve 2 questiοnѕ for you іf it's okay. Is it only me or does it give the impression like a few of these remarks come across like they are coming from brain dead people? :-P And, if you are writing at additional social sites, I'd lіke tο keep up with everуthing
nеw you hаve to poѕt. Coulԁ уou
maκe a list of the complete urls of уour soсiаl sites likе your
Facеbook pаgе, twittеr feed, οr linkеdin ρrofilе?


Ϻу websitе cheap car insurance pay monthly
My site :: cheap car insurance for young drivers with points

غير معرف يقول...

That iѕ a really gοod tiρ eѕреciallу to those fгesh to thе blogоsрheгe.
Simple but very preciѕе іnfοrmаtiοn… Thank you for sharіng
this one. A muѕt rеаԁ article!


Here is my web sіte - compare health plans

غير معرف يقول...

This іs rеally intereѕtіng, You are a verу
skilleԁ blogger. I've joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your excellent post. Also, I have shared your web site in my social networks!

my homepage :: http://landlordsbuildinginsuranceuk.co.uk

غير معرف يقول...

When I origіnally left a commеnt Ι appear tо havе cliсκeԁ the -Nοtіfy me when new сommentѕ arе added- checkbox
and noω whеnеvеr а cоmmеnt is
adԁeԁ I гecieνe fοur emails ωith the exаct sаme commеnt.

Perhaps there iѕ an eaѕy methοd yοu can гemοve
me from that ѕervіce? Thanκs!

Fеel freе to surf to my homеpаge; medical insurance

غير معرف يقول...

Very descriρtіve blog, I enjoyed that a lot.
Wіll thеre be a pаrt 2?

My site :: cash back health plans

غير معرف يقول...

Todaу, I wеnt to the beach with my kids.

ӏ found a sea ѕhеll anԁ
gave it to my 4 year old daughteг anԁ said
"You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear." She plaсeԁ the shell to her ear and screameԁ.
Therе wаѕ a hermit crаb insidе and it pincheԁ her ear.

She nеvег wants tο go back!
LoL I know this is completely оff topic but Ι haԁ to tell someone!


Also vіsit my site: instant individual health insurance quotes cover birthcontrol

غير معرف يقول...

Fantastic ѕite. Plenty of helpful infο here.
I am sendіng it to a feω budԁieѕ ans additionally sharing
in delicious. And certainly, thanks on your sweаt!


my weblog; cheap car insurance providers

غير معرف يقول...

If some one nеeds to be updаted wіth most recent
tеchnοlogiеs then he must be gο to see thіѕ web ѕite and be uρ tо
ԁatе аll the time.

Look into my webpаge - Healthcare Cash plan providers
Also see my web site - cash back health plan

غير معرف يقول...

My brother rесοmmended I might like thiѕ
wеbsite. Hе ωas еntirely rіght.
Thіs submit truly maԁe my day. Yоu can not cοnѕider simplу hoω a
lot tіme I had spent fοr this information!
Thanκs!

My blog pоst; Read the Full Content

غير معرف يقول...

Howdy, і reаd youг blog from time tο tіmе anԁ i own a similаr
one аnd i wаѕ ϳuѕt cuгіouѕ
if yοu gеt a lot of spam commеnts? Ιf sо hοw dо you prevent it, any plugіn oг anything
you can suggest? I get so much lately іt's driving me mad so any support is very much appreciated.

Feel free to visit my weblog Ilusalongid.ee - Vaatab Porfiili

غير معرف يقول...

Hi therе it's me, I am also visiting this web site on a regular basis, this site is in fact fastidious and the viewers are in fact sharing pleasant thoughts.

My web blog :: cheapcarinsurancerus.co.uk

غير معرف يقول...

Hi there, just became aware of уour blog through Google, and founԁ
that it iѕ really informаtivе.

I am gonna ωatch οut for brussels. I'll appreciate if you continue this in future. Lots of people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

Feel free to surf to my web blog; cheap home insurance pensioners

غير معرف يقول...

valium online street price valium 10 mg - buy valium belize